I enjoyed especially the cozy atmosphere at this little place. The walls were full of books, bottles and pictures and gave the restaurant the look of a hedonistic library.
Now Pink Pony is gone. The blog Bowery Boogie reports that the place closed "under cover of darkness" (boweryboogie). It seems that the restaurant got victim of the steep rising rents in this area.
R.I.P. Pink Pony, we will miss you.