Thursday, July 24, 2025

Books: The Alice Behind Wonderland By Simon Winchester






 (Drivebycuriosity) - There are not many pieces of world literature that are so funny and so much pleasure to read like Lewis Carroll´s "Alice's Adventures in Wonderland", better known as  "Alice in Wonderland". Charles Lutwidge 
Dodgson, the real name of the author, dedicated the novel to a then six year old girl, Alice Pleasance Liddell, the daughter of the dean of Christ Church College, Oxford, where Dodgson was employed as sub-librarian & mathematics lecturer.

Simon Winchester wrote a fine little book around Dodgson, Alice, and the most famous portrait of said Alice: "The Alice behind Wonderland" (amazon ). Aged 25 Dodgson became fascinated with photography, then a flegdling art. He took a lot effort to become a master in the new medium and gained popularity as photographer of portraits, often of celebrities like Lord Alfred Tennyson, but he also got fond of portraying little children. 

Being friend with superior dean Liddell and his family gave Dodgson the opportunity to create photographic images of the Liddell children; and Alice became his favorite and friend till the end of her childhood. Winchester just reports the facts and does not participate in the speculation why Dodgson created so many portraits of children, some of them naked. He writes:

"His utter fascination with all of these girls, his need to picture them with or without clothing, his need to make them happy, to amuse them, to have them think of him as a friend and for him to feel free to do the same, his needs to buy them dresses and stocking and bonnets and shoes, and on rare occasions to exhibit brief flashes of physical affection, reflect an aspect of Charles Dodgson`s character that puzzles and intrigues to this day". The usually timid Victorian society did not take offense and Dogdson/Carroll stayed all his life reputable as mathematician, author & artist.

Dodgson - who created a catalogue of about three thousand photographies in his lifetime - made altogether 11 portraits of Alice Liddell alone; the most famous of them - and the focus of the book - is now kept on the Princeton University campus, in the Firestone Library, New Jersey, USA. The object is dressed in a ragged beggar-maid-a costume inspired by a Tennyson poem. "She is lazing coquettishly against a grumbling garden wall of limestone and sandstone, standing in a corner in her bare feet". 

Winchester asks if mother Liddell, a sister, or Miss Prickett, the governess, were present when Dodgson arranged the photo: "The garment has been decorously disarranged - her shoulder both visible, her elbows and lower arms, and her chest" and he wonders "would anyone care that Dodgson then reached behind the little girl´s hair and adjusted the off-white garment about her shoulders, such that it fell slightly from her left and exposed only just entirely her left nipple?". 

Winchester also elaborates about the first steps of the new medium, the competing inventions & technologies and the substantial preparations necessary to create a photographic image. According to Winchester "photography had a kind of manageable madness to it". 

I found this book because I became a fan of Winchester after reading "The Professor And The Madman" (my review) and recently "The River At The Center Of The World: A Journey Up The Yangtze And Back In Chinese Time" ( review). I am impressed how he mastered very different subjects and shaped them all into elegant prose.
 


 

No comments:

Post a Comment